Red Dots Reviewed by the Pearce Brothers
Transcript
Welcome to another episode of The Pierce Brothers! I’m Joe, and today we’ll be diving into pistol red dot optics and exploring the best options currently on the market. Before we get started, we want to give a big shoutout to our supporters on Patreon—thank you! Your contributions make this channel possible, and we’re excited to keep growing with your help. Please like, comment, subscribe, and share to support us even further.
Open vs. Enclosed Optics: The Key Differences
Over the past month, we’ve conducted a series of torture tests on various optics, with more tests planned in the future. These tests help us evaluate durability, performance, and value. Let’s start by discussing open versus enclosed optics.
For enclosed optics, we tested models like the Holosun EPS and the Aimpoint Acro P2. Our torture tests showed that while enclosed optics offer protection against the elements, they come with one major drawback: if the seal is compromised, water or fog can render the optic unusable. This was evident during our Aimpoint Acro test. After a drop test, the seal broke, allowing water to enter the optic. While it maintained zero, the sight became completely fogged, making it impossible to use without removing the optic entirely.
In contrast, open optics like the Trijicon RMR performed exceptionally well. Mud, water, and debris could be quickly blown or wiped away, allowing us to keep shooting with minimal downtime. The RMR held zero throughout our rigorous drop, water, and mud tests, proving its reliability under harsh conditions.
Budget vs. High-End Options
The Vortex Defender is a budget-friendly option priced around $300, compared to the $600 price tag of the Trijicon RMR. During our tests, the Defender performed admirably, maintaining functionality despite minor shifts in windage after the torture tests. However, its fog resistance wasn’t as effective as the RMR’s.
For those seeking an affordable yet reliable red dot, the Vortex Defender is an excellent choice. It offers impressive durability and features like auto shutoff after 10 minutes. On the other hand, the Trijicon RMR’s superior fog resistance and consistent zero retention make it worth the higher price tag for those who can afford it.
Specific Use Cases and Additional Considerations
We also tested the EOTech EFLX, which features a large window and excellent zero retention, making it ideal for calibers like 10mm and .45 ACP. However, its shorter battery life and lack of auto shutoff are drawbacks.
A note on auto-adjust brightness: While this feature can be helpful, it may hinder visibility in low-light scenarios with weapon-mounted lights. In such cases, the dot may appear too dim to see clearly against a brightly illuminated target. To counter this, practice with your setup and manually adjust the brightness to an appropriate level.
Optic Cuts: Factory vs. Custom
Most modern pistols come with factory optics cuts, allowing for easy mounting using adapter plates. However, custom optic cuts can improve functionality by lowering the optic’s profile and creating a more natural grip angle. Custom cuts also provide a firmer mount and allow for better co-witnessing with iron sights. The downside is reduced flexibility in swapping optics, as the cut is tailored to a specific footprint.
Final Thoughts and Recommendations
After extensive testing, my top pick is the Trijicon RMR due to its unmatched durability, fog resistance, and ability to hold zero. If you’re on a budget, the Vortex Defender is a strong contender that offers great value for its price.
We’ll continue testing optics like the Holosun and others, so stay tuned for more results. If there’s a specific red dot you’d like us to test, let us know in the comments! Thanks for watching, and don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more great content.
– Joe, The Pierce Brothers
